Two quotations for anchors of similar mass disagree. Neither may be wrong: each belongs to an anchor in a particular ground, measured by a particular test. IACS UR A1 states the dependence at the level of the rule: the equipment is designed to hold a ship in good holding ground, and in poor holding ground the holding power of the anchors is significantly reduced [1]. The same rule requires a high holding power design to be tested on more than one type of bottom, an acknowledgement that one seabed does not stand in for the rest [1]. What follows is the seabed side: what A1 assumes about the ground, what the 2× and 4× labels compare, which bottoms the approval test covers, and what a claim must name before two figures can be compared.
What A1 assumes about the bottom
The anchoring equipment is intended for temporary mooring of a ship within a harbour or sheltered area while awaiting berth, tide and similar [1]. It is not designed to hold a ship off fully exposed coasts in rough weather, nor to stop a ship that is moving or drifting; in that condition the loads rise to a level at which components may be damaged or lost [1].
The equipment is designed to hold a ship in good holding ground in conditions such as to avoid dragging of the anchor, and in poor holding ground the holding power of the anchors is significantly reduced [1]. The second half is the operative one: the same anchor, in ground the rule would not call good, does not deliver the same figure. Holding power is a property of an anchor-and-ground pair, not of the anchor alone.
The design basis is bounded too: the equipment-number formulae rest on stated assumptions about current, wind and minimum scope, and the rule assumes one bow anchor and one chain cable at a time [1]. The values are not reproduced here; the basis is an envelope, not an open-ended capability. A1 is the IACS baseline — the vessel's class rules and project requirements still govern.
What "HHP 2×" actually compares
The labels are defined by comparison, and the comparison has a stated basis. A high holding power anchor has a holding power of at least twice that of an ordinary stockless anchor of the same mass, and is to be suitable for ship's use without prior adjustment or special placement on the sea bottom [1]. A super high holding power anchor is defined the same way at four times that of an ordinary stockless anchor of the same mass [1].
Two words carry most of the weight: same mass. The multiple is not a statement about sand or mud, nor a claim that an anchor holds twice as much as a larger one. It comes from two anchors of approximately the same mass, each tested with the chain size required for that mass [1]. Change the mass or the bottom and it no longer applies.
The labels are performance classes, not product ratings. An anchor described as HHP has met a class definition against a reference anchor; the definition certifies no particular casting and no seabed. SHHP, at four times, is a class with a narrower field of use [1]. When one document says 2× and another 4×, they may describe two classes, or one class against different references. The question to settle is which comparison, at which mass, on which bottom; the testing behind the classification is in the HHP approval article.
The three test bottoms
A1 does not leave the result to one bottom. Full-scale tests are to be carried out at sea on various types of bottom, normally soft mud or silt, sand or gravel, and hard clay or similar compounded material, on anchors of mass as far as possible representative of the sizes proposed [1].
| Bottom family (A1 wording) | What the test puts the anchor into | What the result does not settle |
|---|---|---|
| Soft mud or silt | A fine-grained, low-strength bottom; the name does not fix its strength or density | A figure for a granular or stiff bottom |
| Sand or gravel | A granular bottom whose density and grading the name does not fix | A result for a denser or layered bed |
| Hard clay or similar compounded material | A stiff cohesive bottom | A result for other clay strengths or mixed ground |
The three families are coverage, not a ranking: a claim has to survive more than one ground before it is accepted as a class, and nothing in A1 assigns an order of merit to them.
The protocol inside each bottom is what makes the numbers repeatable. The two anchors are to be of approximately the same mass and tested with the chain size required for that mass [1]. Cable length is to be such that the pull on the shank remains horizontal, for which a scope of 10 is considered normal but not less than 6 may be accepted [1]. Three tests are to be taken for each anchor and each type of bottom, and the test load is not to exceed the proof load of the anchor [1]. A figure obtained at a scope below 6, or without a horizontal pull, is not the test the rule describes.
What changes the result inside "sand" or "clay"
The three names are families, not specifications, and the variables that decide penetration sit inside them. Sharif et al. list the anchor size, usually taken as its mass, the fluke length, the fluke angle or opening angle, and the soil type into which the anchor is deployed [2]. A report that says "sand" has fixed none of the properties behind the word.
A bottom may not be one material. Nakamura and Honda present a method of estimating the holding power of an anchor in sea-bottom soil mixed with sand and clay, built on the mixture ratio of the two and on the ratio of maximum dragging pull to anchor weight from model tests in sand and in clay [3]. They conclude that the effects of anchor shape factors and soil conditions on holding power may be predicted from model tests, with calculated results showing fairly good agreement with actual anchor tests [3]. Their coefficients are not reproduced here: they belong to the 1973 test series and its units, and do not transfer as a general value.
What a model test can and cannot tell you
The paper also states its limits. Sharif et al. compared the penetration behaviour of a Class F (AC-14) anchor in loose soil using centrifuge and 1-g model scale testing, and reported that the 1-g testing can match the behaviour in the centrifuge in terms of both the position of the anchor and its orientation during the dragging event [2].
Three limits are built in. The soil was loose sand, so the agreement holds in that soil. The comparison covers position and orientation during dragging, not holding capacity in every ground. The authors list other densities, clays and layered soils as further work [2], so the result does not extend to them. A model test studies a mechanism under controlled conditions; it neither substitutes for a full-scale test on the bottom in question nor supports a statement about an anchor in service.
A full-scale approval test and a model test can produce numbers that look alike and answer different questions: one supports a class definition under a stated protocol, the other describes behaviour inside a soil and a scale. A report that does not say which it is has not told the reader what the number means. How the AC-14 is designed and classified is in the AC-14 anchor article.
What to ask when someone quotes a holding power
Five items make a claim comparable: the anchor design and mass tested, the bottom named in the terms the test used, the test method and scale, the scope and pull direction, and whether the figure is a class approval or a model-test result. No document supplies a holding number valid without them.
| Claim element | Why it matters | What to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Anchor design and mass tested | The 2× and 4× labels are same-mass comparisons [1] | Which design and mass, against which reference anchor? |
| Bottom tested | Approval covers three bottom families; the figure belongs to one [1] | Which family, and how was the site soil described? |
| Test method and scale | An approval test and a model test answer different questions [2] | Full-scale at sea, or model, in which soil? |
| Scope and pull direction | A scope of about 10 with a horizontal shank pull is normal, 6 a minimum [1] | What scope, and was the pull horizontal? |
| Status of the figure | A class definition is not a project capacity [1] | Approval result, model result, or catalogue claim? |
Status is easily left out. Japan P&I states the failure condition plainly: a ship's anchor drags because external forces on it exceed the holding power of the anchor and cable [5]. A quoted holding power is therefore a threshold, not a margin: it says what load the anchor and cable are expected to resist in the ground tested, not how much wind or sea that represents for a ship.
What this means for selection
Compare within one test basis. Two figures from the same protocol, bottom family and pull arrangement can be set side by side. A figure from sand against one from soft mud cannot, and a 2× class label against a 4× label compares two definitions rather than two anchors on one site.
Then check the site against the premise. DNV's condition — horizontal chain on the seabed and good holding ground — is where the rule's assumption meets the anchorage, and where the ground is poor the rule itself reduces the expectation [1][4]. Since many anchorages lie outside sheltered waters, the premise has to be verified for the project rather than assumed [4].
Product pages identify the designs a supplier offers; they are not a holding-power statement for a particular bottom and replace no test report. The marine anchor category and the AC-14 HHP anchor page are two entry points; the mechanics behind the figures are in the anchor holding power article.
Send the anchor design and mass, the bottom and test conditions behind any quoted holding power, the applicable rule set and the project's anchorage data so that a figure is read against the conditions it came from rather than as a standalone rating.
References
[1] IACS, UR A1 — Anchoring Equipment, Rev.7 2020/Corr.1 2021 — https://ww2.eagle.org/content/dam/eagle/regulatory-news/2022/IACS-UR-A1.pdf
[2] Sharif, Y.U. et al. (2024), Comparison of the behaviour of a drag embedment anchor using 1-g and centrifuge scale model testing, ECPMG 2024 — https://www.issmge.org/uploads/publications/53/125/ECPMG2024-78.pdf
[3] Nakamura, S. & Honda, K. (1973), Experimental Study on Holding Power of Anchor, Journal of the Kansai Society of Naval Architects, Japan — https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/kansaiks/149/0/149_31/_article/-char/en
[4] DNV (2021), Anchor losses are on a negative trend — How to improve, Technical and Regulatory News 23/2021 — https://www.dnv.com/news/2021/anchor-losses-are-on-a-negative-trend-how-to-improve-211092/
[5] The Japan Ship Owners' Mutual Protection & Indemnity Association (2013), Preventing an Anchor from Dragging, Loss Prevention Bulletin Vol.25 — https://www.piclub.or.jp/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/Loss-Prevention-Bulletin-Vol.25-Light.pdf


